Help us make our $25,000 match. Become a member today!

Mistake in First California Carbon Auction Raises Questions About Secrecy

By Craig Miller, KQED News Fix

California’s cap-and-trade program to cut greenhouse gases resumed this week with its second auction of carbon allowances to industrial polluters. The market is being closely watched around the world, and billions of dollars are at stake. But some nagging questions are lingering from the first auction.

The state’s first-ever carbon auction last November was a very exclusive online event, open only to bidders and regulators at the California Air Resources Board (CARB). Four days later, Mary Nichols, who heads the board, declared it a resounding success, saying the auction came off "without a hitch."

"Hundreds of participants were trained at every stage of the process, including how to register and how to bid," Nichols told reporters in a victory-lap news conference. "And it all worked just as we had hoped it would." Well, not quite “all.” One of the biggest players in the auction encountered a rather sizable hitch that Nichols never mentioned. More  than a month later, Bloomberg reported that one of California’s largest utilities, Southern California Edison, had inadvertently bought about 40 percent more permits than it intended. Bloomberg said it obtained internal documents revealing that Edison bidders had used “the wrong format” to submit its bid.

Read the complete story at KQED News Fix.